Walter Wong, the permit expediter for the 555 Fulton Street project and head of the W. Wong Construction Company, has agreed to repay the City for $1.45 million in no-bid contracts and grants awarded to Wong and his companies by San Francisco’s Department of Public Works, the SFPUC, and a grant administered by the City Administrator’s Office in exchange for gifts he provided to then-Public Works Director Mohammed Nuru and the then-General Manager of the SFPUC, Harlan Kelly.
In addition, Wong will pay $317,650 in penalties and late fees for failing to disclose campaign contributions and contacts as a permit expediter and will be barred from doing business with the City or acting as a permit expediter for a period of five years.
At the same time, Wong is awaiting sentencing on federal charges of conspiring to defraud the public, “through a scheme involving bribery, kickbacks, and the concealment of material information,” as well as having conspired with Nuru and others, “to engage in money laundering, to disguise and conceal the proceeds of fraud,” charges to which he pled guilty last year and the sentencing for which is conditioned upon his agreement to provide “information, documents, and testimony to the ongoing federal investigation into corruption in San Francisco city government.”
Maybe we should just outlaw permit expediting? I mean why doesn’t everyone face the same process?
Seriously. And maybe have closed permits be a signal that the permitted work actually meets code. Which, to me, seems like the entire point of a permit to begin with. Currently, it simply means the work “appears to be consistent with code” which is completely meaningless.
This would be a fine solution. Everyone should have to follow the law. If the law is broken, fix the law, don’t let rich and connected people create exceptions.
Inspectors usually don’t do a complete check of everything built. They tend to spot check and create punch lists when those spot checks find sub-par work. So it is hard to claim with 100% confidence that the work meets code.
I’ve found all sorts of code violations left behind by contractors who’s work passed inspection. One of the most egregious cases was a live wire I found snipped off inside of a wall. No accessible J-box as required by code. No wire nut. Not even taped off. Just snipped and forgotten.
Wow that is a sweet deal for Walter.
The agreement above is to settle a civil suit brought by the City Attorney.
Wong pled guilty to federal charges of conspiring to defraud the public, “through a scheme involving bribery, kickbacks, and the concealment of material information,” as well as having conspired with Nuru and others “to engage in money laundering, to disguise and conceal the proceeds of fraud,” last year and is awaiting sentencing, which is conditioned upon his agreement “to provide information, documents, and testimony to the ongoing federal investigation into corruption in San Francisco city government,” as since added above.
Why wasn’t this a criminal case?
Wong pled guilty to federal criminal charges of conspiring to defraud the public, “through a scheme involving bribery, kickbacks, and the concealment of material information,” as well as having conspired with Nuru and others “to engage in money laundering, to disguise and conceal the proceeds of fraud,” last year and is awaiting sentencing, which is conditioned upon his agreement “to provide information, documents, and testimony to the ongoing federal investigation into corruption in San Francisco city government.”
The agreement above is to settle a civil suit brought by the City Attorney.
It will be interesting to see whether Nuru, Kelly, or Hui are implicated in this racket.
OK so everybody knows this is the teensy weensy tip of the iceberg, right? When you have over a billion $$ a month sloshing around 49 sq miles (multiples more, for instance, than Riverside County and its cities at 7000-ish square miles!) there is going to be hundreds of millions of that per year going to dubious purposes and squiggly people. We have these non-profits for instance that have metastasized into conglomerations (esp in the Bayview and the Mission) with these kinds of Tzars at the top, raking in tens of millions or more for a bewildering array of “services” with no serious review or performance metrics. And with the feds dumping millions (likely billions) more for everything from COVID to stimulus to sea level rise abatement, its a helluva party these days over at City Hall. And since the number one employer of former news reporters is as spokespersons for the very interests they are supposed to be covering, don’t expect any exposes anytime soon.
Nuru’s already well implicated in this one, isn’t he?
… and then things took a turn towards weird: Embattled former S.F. official arrested in knife incident.
Meanwhile, I was enjoying the link from the Construction Physics website. It is very easy to find San Francisco on all of the various charts looking at construction costs around the world. Their final take:
The US does particularly well at building homes, apartments, and other projects that have low administrative overhead or government involvement.
The US does particularly poorly at projects with a high degree of administrative burden, government oversight, or where the government is a major stakeholder. European countries do far better by comparison. Hello San Francisco!
Why do we need expediters? Because the building department is one big ball of molasses. I’ve offered to pay for permits, revisions, etc. It takes months for them to even take my money. Have one small change and need to resubmit… months of waiting for an appointment. SF DBI and Planning are a total mess.
Which is obviously by design. DBI employees have no interest in moving things along. They all know they will retire to a fat gig as an expeditor. They don’t want to simplify the process.
As someone who gets a lot of projects through the City process – abet minor projects 🙂 – I’ve seen graft dozens of times over the past 20 years. Hopefully it gets better – it really needs to if we are going to build a better city.
The plethora of meaningless rules to enforce, the overly elaborate review processes with no oversight or timelines for completion, leads to a system ripe for corruption. That nonsense just seems to increase every year.
I have just applied for the expeditors job
Since the vacancy opened up
I will only charge builders 10% of the job cost
No permit no pay
95% success rate guaranteed
“A” expeditor job opened up, not “the” expeditor job.
UPDATE: Former San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) General Manager Harlan Kelly has been found guilty of bank and wire fraud related to the actions above.
Only two years since the civil settlement, and God-only-knows-how-long since the actual offense(s)!! Who says justice moves slowly ??
Sun Tzu. The entire quote is “the wheels of justice turn slowly, but they grind exceedingly fine”. In the PRC and/or a number of countries south of California’s southern border, Kelly and Wong would have gotten away with this, secured their ill-gotten gains in offshore bank accounts or real estate investments, successfully passed them on to their family members tax-free and we’d have never heard anything about it.
It’s our institutions and rule of law that makes the U.S. special and desirable, not the ability of anyone to arrive here and pursue realizing their wildest dreams of avarice, which is what some chain-yankers in these comment threads would have you believe.
Or he might have been executed https://apnews.com/article/world-news-tianjin-china-asset-management-2f5d1248477a8e044d9fa7b6899ca406 . No guarantees, either way, of course; so we might say rule of law seeks to achieve more consistent outcomes…even if it doesn’t always find what it was looking for.